AS you all know from my review of Broadway Week, I am not a
fan of themed weeks & so far this series, the couples haven’t needed an
additional excuse to limit their content & increase their use of
props. This is a shame really as many of
the couples don’t need all this ‘ embellishment’ as they are good enough to
produce some really beautiful & memorable DANCE routines. For me the stand out routine so far has been
Chelsee & Pasha Quickstep last week which I really hoped would set the tone
and standard for this weeks dances BUT it wasn’t to be and again I felt a
little let down & disappointed with mostly the celebs who can actually
dance & those who are on the right track to improvement. This is only my opinion and again, I am sure
many of the millions who watch the show probably feel otherwise & perhaps I
need to look at the show through their non professional eyes – I doubt that
will ever happen though ;-)
Russell & Flavia
- Samba
Unfortunately this was not Russell’s week. It seemed to lack his usual exuberance and
flair – perhaps all due to the troubles & worries regarding his knee? It
was still enjoyable to watch and as usual Flavia did a great job with the
content of the dance, there certainly was plenty of it! He had a very routine
full of basic content including: Cruzado walks & locks, Volta’s, Rolling
off the arm, Solo samba section, Circular Voltas, Spot Voltas, Bota Fogas,
Criss Cross Voltas & Walks in shadow position – WOW that’s a lot of content
to remember & learn but well done to Russell for rising to the challenge
which he always does. Perhaps there was
a little too much (I can’t believe I am saying this) though considering all the
problems he was having with his knee & he made a few mistakes, lost his
timing and generally he lacked the sparkle that is required for the Samba. Saying all that though, it was still an
enjoyable dance to watch and I hope he will be back to his usual bubbly self
next week!
Content: 8 Theme:
6 Overall: 6
Chelsee & Pasha – Tango
It was a great intro that wasn’t too long and introduced us
to the dance very nicely. It had a very
nice Tango feel with great neat and sharp lines. The content was fabulous again and consisted
of: Open promenade, Open reverse turn,
Progressive link progressive side step, Reverse turn, Rock step, Tango walks,
locks & chasses, Fallaway promenade, Swivels, Contra check, Fallaway
reverse slip pivot and Oversway – absolutely wonderful display of including so
many basic recognisable steps in a complex and interesting routine &
Chelsee copes so well with all this choreography! I do feel that Chelsee still needs to work on
her upper body strength and frame and also her core muscles, as she can
sometimes look a little floppy, especially when she gets tired as the routine
progresses. She made a little mistake
coming out of their Contra check in the beginning but generally I found it to
be a very entertaining dance with great story telling. I won’t comment much on the wardrobe
malfunction except to say that perhaps the wardrobe department should have
known better than to put her in such a revealing dress with too little support
however, the malfunction made no difference to me in their dancing.
Content: 9 Theme: 8 Overall:
8
Audley & Natalie – Jive
I thought that although their Intro was rather long, it
couldn’t have been much shorter as the song only started properly after all the
faffing at the piano anyway. I did find
the song a bit slow but thought Audley portrayal and character so enjoyable to
watch – he really looks like he enjoys every minute of dancing. For me there was too much use of Lindy hop
steps instead of Jive flicks and kicks & this can make the Jive look heavy
– you don’t need to point your feet or use a fast straightening of the knee in
Lindy Hop kicks either like you do in Jive so this can slow the whole look of
the dance down. The chorus contained a
lot of messing around and repetition & looked a little messy and
unrehearsed. There wasn’t enough proper
Jive content and their dance only contained the following: a small Jive flick & kick section,
chasses, Fallaway throwaway, chicken walks and a variation of rotating check
American Spin. Within this content, I felt that Audley needed to pick his knees
up more & get his weight over the balls of his feel more to create a light
and bouncy Jive action instead of it looking flat footed & heavy. But, I cannot fault his enthusiasm and
enjoyment no matter what dance he is doing!
Content: 5 Theme: 6 Overall:
5
Alex & James – Paso Doble
This is a difficult song to create a great Paso dance to – I
remember Brendan & Sarah Manners using it in series 2 & it was a good
song choice for them so hopefully it will be a good choice for Alex & James
too.
Alex’s interpretation of the song in the long intro was very
good and believable, the acting part usually is always very good for her apart
from last week but I was glad to see her back to herself. They began their Paso content with: Promenade to Counter promenade into Twist
turns into Pivots, all nicely done but I felt it lacked upper body strength,
shape and extension from Alex – she can give it a bit more ‘oomph’ I feel! They
had a nice Paso highlight and drop but it looked a little like Alex hangs onto
James sometimes and in turn causes her to look like James is pulling her into
the next position instead of Alex moving her own body weight. I feel that this is a general problem for
Alex and one she should focus a lot more on fixing. Their Chasse capes were good although there
was a timing issue. On the whole I
thought the use of Alex’s skirt was a little excessive and instead of enhancing
her movement, it exaggerated the overuse of the skirt use in place of
movement. Despite Alex not being a very
aggressive dancer in this Paso, I did feel that her characterisation was in
keeping with the theme James created as Alex still looked herself in the dance
without compromising herself.
Content: 6 Theme:
7 Overall: 7
Holly & Artem - American Smooth
This was a risky, brave, inventive, characteristic,
theatrical & spell binding routine but I was left wondering what type of
American Smooth this was supposed to be as there really were no recognisable
American Smooth steps. There were however
lots of American Smooth lifts, tricks & theatre but for me, that doesn’t
make an American Smooth dance. This
therefore is very difficult to comment on dance wise as there it had hardly any
content to comment technically on – although I thought Holly’s frame, head
position & poise was excellent when she was in hold with Artem. She is very elegant and has beautiful use of
arms and length of line but I would like her to ‘live’ the dance more in
expression and give herself more to the dance… there is a dancer in her just
waiting to break free I am sure.
Content: 4 Theme:
9 Overall: 7
Nancy & Anton – Rumba
This was a great Rumba song choice & I hoped to see some
good, basic Rumba dancing…
Nancy is naturally sexy without even trying to be but, as
for so many female celebs, when it comes to being sexy in Rumba, they just look
the complete opposite and it doesn’t work.
Their Rumba consisted of the following:
1 back basic into a type of underarm turn, Hand to Hand, Rope spin,
double Spiral & Opening out section. It was more recognisable content than
usual but, so poorly executed - The timing was rushed to the point of being
almost out of time, there was no hip action, straightening of knees or foot
pressure into the floor. There was a
lift that was really unflattering and didn’t do anything for Nancy. To be fair though, when Nancy was posing and
not doing too much, she actually looked OK and less is more is definitely what
she could concentrate on when getting into character in the dance however, I
would have like to have seen that she actually was taught basic fundamentals
and work on them instead of all the time wasting and faffing that went on.
Content: 4 Theme:
5 Overall: 4
Harry & Aliona – Tango
I loved the theme and look for their set & their song
was a good choice to set the theme of the dance. Again, a very long intro but it was
captivating and had good story telling and Harry & Aliona were very precise
in their movements and very in tune with each other. Once they did get going, their Tango lacked
considerable basic Tango steps and consisted manly of lines & lunges revolving
around turns and spins to create effect.
The basic steps that I notice were: Walks in promenade, outside Rock
step with flicks, Oversway, half Standing Spin, Turning Locks & Backward
rocks however, there was a lack of movement around the dance floor i.e. using
all available dance space in a moving dance along the line of dance & this
is reflected in the lack of moving Tango steps and rather too much usage of
static ‘effect’ steps. It is a shame as
Harry really is a good dancer and has a good frame & looks the part on the
dance floor. I would just like to see
him do more of what he is capable of doing.
Content: 4 Theme:
9 Overall: 7
Robbie & Ola – Paso Doble
I thought their music choice could have been great if they
had used all the musical accents & syncopations but instead, they used too
many whole beats consecutively to dance to and not enough syncopations which in
turn made it look heavy & slow instead of their Paso having pace &
power. A little too much ‘walking
timing’. It surprisingly lacked Paso shapes
due to a lack of bent knees and pelvis forward posture with upper body rotation,
which in turn creates a strong Paso shape.
Paso shape also needs to be created by using your sides in opposition to
each other meaning that whilst one side is stretching, the other is compressing
to create side shaping.
Their dance also lacked enough basic steps to show off these
tradition Paso features and only contained promenade & counter promenade
with Pivot ending repeated, lots of Paso walks but not a lot of Paso dancing
& a variation of Chasse Cape. I felt
that there was a lack of commitment to the steps with power & aggression
& a lack of strong heel leads & foot speed to create more of marching
feel rather than a walking feel. It also looked as if Robbie wasn’t really in
charge of the dance or of Ola.
I felt that the over use of the ‘crotch grabbing’ was inappropriate
& excessive for the theme of the dance and generally I was disappointed
with this dance as I am usually a fan of Robbie’s exuberance and love for
dancing. On this occasion however, it
didn’t look like he was truly into this dance.
However, I thought his cape work was very good & brave of him to
attempt when so much could go wrong.
Content: 4 Theme: 6 Overall: 5
Anita & Robin – Tango
Great acting & characterisation from Anita & she is
at her best when she can sink her teeth in to a strong role & theme.
This was thankfully a good and quick Intro and straight into
some great Tango choreography: Fallaway
reverse, Forward locks, Turning locks, Oversway, Swivels, The Chase & Flick
tap steps in Promenade & all done within character. I would however like to have seen a more
staccato Tango action & it could have been a bit more aggressive &
attacking in leg & body action with more of a staccato foot action. Anita’s frame was a little passive for me and
she could have used her head more sharply & had more of an ‘aloof’ upper
body extension. I felt it lacked speed
and for me it never quite got going in terms of power & movement & there were a number of mistakes in The
Chase step & a little too much time wasting in the middle of the dance
however, the characterisation was superb & lovely to watch.
Content: 7 Theme:
7 Overall: 7
Lulu & Brendan – Paso Doble
Theatrically, Brendan never fails to impress & come up
with some entertaining routine whether you like it or not! I liked this &
it seemed so did Lulu. Once again a very
long intro but, it was very entertaining and theatrical and leant itself to the
theme of the dance so almost forgiven.
Lulu was very convincing in character and I felt that this was
definitely one of her better dances. She
has put her trust in Brendan and this shows and great to see that Brendan also trusts
her with more content and that she will work hard at remembering it. There was great movement and coverage of the
dance floor and I enjoyed the use of their bat wings to enhance their shapes
and not detract from it – they looked like choreographed arm movements. Their Paso consisted of a number of great
basic steps: Bota Fogas in shadow position, Paso Locks. Grand Circle, Flamenco
group, Twist Turns & Chasse Capes. I
did however feel that the basic steps in hold lacked strong shapes fro Lulu
& that she needs to work on strengthening her core & frame to stop her
looking like Brendan is also pulling her around. She sometimes looked unsure of her timing
& exact footwork but she is getting better at covering these things up
& is such a fantastic performer to the point where if you blinked you’d
miss the errors.
Content: 6 Theme: 8 Overall: 7
Jason & Kristina – Quickstep
Jason is the ultimate performer, great at characterisation & so watchable & this dance was no exception. I thought him to be very brave to dance a bit
of Quickstep without Kristina & therefore proving that he can dance on his
own without relying on his partner dancing around him to make him look
good. I loved their look – classy,
elegant & non-detracting from their dancing but rather enhancing it. They danced very in sync with each other with
great body contact in some very difficult steps & the content of their
dance was very impressive: Series of hops, skips, chasses & Jumps in
Promenade, Charleston, Standing spin, Chasses in Promenade, Locks & runs,
Running Finish, Running right turn & 4 Quick Run. Making for a well-rounded Quickstep. Jason also has a very strong frame
throughout, it looks natural and easy to maintain and not contrived at
all. There Quickstep had a great energy
to it and maintained a good Quickstep feel although I do think at times that
Jason does get a bit carried away and needs a little more refinement &
finesse. It is such a shame he made a
mistake in the Promenade run section – I am sure he will be so angry at himself
for that but don’t dwell on it Jason. It
was my 2nd favourite Quickstep of the series!
Content: 9 Theme:
9 Overall: 9
As you can see, I’ve decided that the only way to fairly
mark this weeks dances is to divide the marks into sections of amount of
content (not necessarily how it was executed, the theme of the dance and an
overall mark). This was because so many
dances lacked content but had good themes.
Let’s hope this will be the last time I will have to do this until the ‘show
dances’ but, perhaps it is time to revise how we look at and mark the dances on
Strictly Come Dancing now, especially since it is so far removed from what the
programme was originally all about – the dancing. It wasn’t too long ago when
the use of props, themes, long intros & effects wasn’t allowed or even
considered i.e. When Alesha & Matthew Cutler won with pure dance ability.
Perhaps the marks should now be reflected something like
this: Content, Technical Merit &
Overall mark? Perhaps we may get fairer
marks this way as it really is becoming increasingly difficult to mark this
competition on dancing alone especially as there is so little of it these days.
Although the addition of all the ‘extras’ makes for
entertaining viewing, it does make it more difficult to watch & judge purely
as a Ballroom & Latin American dance competition which for me is a shame as
I enjoy watching the progress made in the dancing more than watching the
spectacle.
For me, it is always a pleasure watching someone actually
learning to dance, mastering the steps & gaining a sense of achievement
from learning a very difficult skill and a beautiful art form that is Ballroom
& Latin American dancing.
See you all next week. x